In its early years, it was looked after by George Nutting and his wife, who would eventually leave all their property, house, and money to the camp. In 1957, the camp entered the construction process and began with the dining hall, then the creation of the beach, and finally the ten cabins. The 1694 administration building (still used today!), Memorial Lodge (now Prescott Lodge), and the boat house came with the property. The Tremont Temple Log Cabin Chapel would not be constructed until 1965.
On the very first day, of the very first camp, Matson had to send the campers home due to a septic system back up, they would return the next day. In 1959, three modular homes were donated from M.I.T and today they are Red Lodge, Grey Lodge, and M.I.T. Lodge.
Matson loved the outdoors and wanted an outdoor camping area and by 1960, Sargis Matson Pioneer Village was complete with custom made covered wagons, and later pitched canvas tents. Today, only scattered remnants of these remain, sitting in the woods as a reminder of the way camp began.